Ars Technica: Many people have noted the coincidence that the FAA’s SMART AI system was rolled out nationwide the same week as the router issue that caused the ground shutdown. The FAA has said SMART’s launch had no connection to what followed. What is your opinion on all this?
man: I understand. I think it’s a coincidence. This particular router was just one in a long series of replacements being made – they don’t take 1000 routers and just replace them all on a Thursday. They could do one or two a night for a couple of years.
Now, just to dig into it a little bit, it could be entirely possible that the capabilities of the router, or perhaps something that has been configured or misconfigured, is a technology that facilitates SMART. In other words, it’s not intended to be used now, but they’re putting in a placeholder.
If you have a deployment, you have three steps. You have step A, B, C. Well, if you need a super fast, ridiculously powerful switch or something on step C, you can put it on step A, knowing that you’re not using its full capacity, because that’s when it makes sense to do it. Maybe it’s difficult infrastructure, physically difficult to do or whatever.
But you put the super fast switch on A, then you do step B, then you do step C, and only at that point, when you get to step C, are you really going to start using the capabilities of that switch. And those could be years apart. I imagine something like that would be subtext.
But the thing is, the SMART system looks weeks and months into the future. It doesn’t touch the operation. It reads data, does some things, and makes some advisory comments and predictions, and then it tells the people in the air traffic control center, “Hey, you might want to do this.”
As far as I know and in my opinion, the SMART system does not touch the actual operational data. In other words, it is not something that extends to the entire network. You have certain data sets that are in the control center or wherever you are. There is certain data that you have access to that you cannot insert information into. It just relies on data and does analysis, and then provides a recommendation to traffic managers, and then those traffic managers act or don’t act on that information in some way.