The researchers argued that cutting grants amounted to viewpoint discrimination that violated the First Amendment. A district court agreed and issued an injunction restoring grants awarded to these researchers.
This decision was upheld by an appeals court. It was decided that the government does have the option of withdrawing the subsidies programs The cancellation of individual funding with which she did not agree was an attempt to “suppress dangerous ideas”. To support this claim, it cited Supreme Court precedent regarding religious discrimination.
The court ruled that DEI fits within this framework because it “transmits[s] the position that the exclusion of historically disadvantaged groups is undesirable.” As a result, “the government has not only exercised its authority to select the programs it funds, but has instead terminated individual grants in existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of individual speakers.”
Assuming this case continues, the Supreme Court could find other ways to intervene. But the fact that she hasn’t now is remarkable, considering that she could have easily objected to everything from the venue to the ruling that the government’s actions constituted viewpoint discrimination. And the government’s lack of intervention could be interpreted by other courts as a sign that the government’s anti-DEI efforts rest on shaky legal ground.